Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Sephora Favorites, Draw The Line Eyeliner Sampler Review

*Picture from website

This came with 3 full sized eyeliners, and 3 sample sized eyeliners.

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Perversion.
  • Full Size
  • Thin brush for a sharp, precise line. 
  • Loved the staying power of this eyeliner! I used this eyeliner when I went on a cruise to the Caribbean and it stayed on ALL day and night! 
  • Comes off easy with no harsh rubbing. 

Kat Von D Tattoo Liner in Trooper
  • Sample.
  •  The brush tip makes it easy for you to make a thin or thick line.
This one was my favorite. It doesn't last as long as the Urban Decay one does, but the application isn't that dark, which I preferred, and if I wanted the color to be darker, I just applied another layer. 

Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Eyeliner in Midnight Black.
  •  Full size
  •  Does not come with a brush so you have to use your own.
  • I found that this gel eyeliner dried out pretty quickly, so you need to be quick. 

Buxom Insider Eyeliner in Black Jasper. 
  • Sample
  • Retractable Eyeliner.
  • Smooth Application.
  • Good for tight-lining. 

Sephora Collection Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner in Glitter Black.
  • Full Size
  • Includes a smudge brush at the end so you can smudge out your eyeliner. (Though when you smudge it out, the color almost completely disappears.)
  • I loved the little hint of glitter it included!

Make Up Forever Aqua Eyes Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner in Mat black.
  • Sample
  • Dark enough to look like a liquid eyeliner, but not to the point to where it looks sharp.

Loved this pencil eyeliner the best! My HG pencil eyeliner is Urban Decay 24/7, but I use this one just as much. 

*I used the hubby's arm by the way. haha. My number one supporter!! :) 

From L-R: Urban Decay, Kat Von D, Make Up Forever, Buxom, Sephora, and Smashbox. 
The Buxom eyeliner isn't a true black and you can see how glittery the Sephora eyeliner is. 

The Smashbox eyeliner is starting to run. 

After lightly rubbing it.
The Buxom, Sephora, and Smashbox eyeliners are starting to disappear while the UD, KVD, and MUFE eyeliners are still completely on.

After rubbing it like crazy! Haha.
As you can see the Urban Decay one is STILL completely there. The Kat Von D eyeliner started to fade, but not as bad as the others. I was disappointed to see the Make Up Forever eyeliner rub off! It did so well! 

So, if you are looking for a waterproof eyeliner that lasts ALL day, through rain or shine...your best bet is to get the Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Eyeliner. 


  1. Wow this set looks amazing! I wish they had Sephora over here in the UK. Great find x

    1. I never knew that! Do they have anything similar to Sephora over there?

  2. Great set! Lovely haul :) Cool blog too!

    I would appreciate it if you would visit my blog too! :)
    xx ♥

  3. What a great kit, the eyeliners look amazing! x